Demo 2 · owned fleet vs external hire, gated by operator competency
| Req. | Project | Machine | Dates | Allocation | Cost | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| R1 | P-101 Northfield Reserve | excavator 20t | Mon 09–Fri 13 Nov | External wet hire | $10,480 | EX20-01: available, but no eligible operator Mark Delaney: ticket expired 2026-10-28 Aisha Rahman: not inducted for Northfield Reserve Ben Kowalski: allocated to R4 (only current grader operator) Hamish Ford: not inducted for Northfield Reserve |
| R2 | P-106 Westmead hockey centre | excavator 8t | Mon 09–Thu 12 Nov | EX08-01 + Aisha Rahman | $3,216 | Owned plant $2,036 cheaper than wet hire ($5,252) |
| R3 | P-106 Westmead hockey centre | excavator 8t | Wed 11–Fri 13 Nov | EX08-02 + Hamish Ford service booked Mon 09 Nov first | $2,352 | Owned plant $1,712 cheaper than wet hire ($4,064) |
| R4 | P-102 Eastvale College | laser grader | Tue 10–Thu 12 Nov | GR-01 + Ben Kowalski | $3,432 | Owned plant $5,492 cheaper than wet hire ($8,924) |
| R5 | P-103 Riverbend estate | skid steer | Mon 09–Fri 13 Nov | SS-01 + Dylan Tran | $3,460 | Owned plant $1,600 cheaper than wet hire ($5,060) |
| R6 | P-103 Riverbend estate | skid steer | Mon 09–Fri 13 Nov | External wet hire | $5,060 | SS-01: allocated to R5 SS-02: breakdown until 2026-11-12 Aisha Rahman: not inducted for Riverbend estate Hamish Ford: not inducted for Riverbend estate Rosa Mendes: allocated to R7 Dylan Tran: allocated to R5 |
| R7 | P-104 Kingsford Park | roller 12t | Thu 12–Fri 13 Nov | RL-12 + Rosa Mendes | $1,480 | Owned plant $1,580 cheaper than wet hire ($3,060) |
An operator is only allocated if they hold a current ticket for the machine, the client-site induction, and are available. Owned cost = fuel + maintenance per engine hour + operator day rate. Hire = wet-hire rate + floats + fuel. Fixed ownership costs are excluded from the comparison because they are incurred whether or not the machine works.
| Item | Owner | Due | |
|---|---|---|---|
| RED | Mark Delaney — excavator ticket expired 28 Oct | Plant & Compliance Coordinator | this week |
| AMBER | Ben Kowalski — laser_grader ticket expires 24 Nov — only current holder of this ticket | Plant & Compliance Coordinator | before 24 Nov |
| AMBER | EX08-02 — book service Mon 09 Nov before R3 | Workshop Supervisor | 09 Nov |
| AMBER | EX20-01 — 4 breakdown days in 8 weeks; review reliability | Workshop Supervisor | 2 weeks |
| AMBER | SS-02 — 5 breakdown days in 8 weeks; review reliability | Workshop Supervisor | 2 weeks |
| REVIEW | TT-01 — 22% utilised over 8 weeks; assess with 12 months of seasonal data before any hire-vs-own decision | Operations Director | day-30 review |
| Asset | Utilisation | Breakdown days | Charged to projects | Ownership + running cost | Contribution | Hours to service |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EX20-01 20t excavator (GPS) | 60% | 4 | $27,600 | $17,388 | $10,212 | 80 |
| EX08-01 8t excavator | 82% | 0 | $23,760 | $11,076 | $12,684 | 390 |
| EX08-02 8t excavator | 75% | 2 | $21,600 | $10,634 | $10,966 | 15 |
| GR-01 Laser-controlled grader | 52% | 0 | $30,450 | $19,776 | $10,674 | 400 |
| SS-01 Skid steer loader | 88% | 0 | $16,800 | $7,284 | $9,516 | 200 |
| SS-02 Skid steer loader | 65% | 5 | $12,480 | $6,140 | $6,340 | 250 |
| RL-12 12t smooth-drum roller | 45% | 0 | $11,160 | $6,080 | $5,080 | 140 |
| TT-01 Tractor + topdresser | 22% | 0 | $4,860 | $4,308 | $552 | 220 |